I'm drinking a Dry Stout that I brewed. If I were to enter it into a competition, I'd say I would not win. Infact, I'd say I'd come pretty close to last. The reason is because I don't think it tastes very nice. There is a very sharp acridity about it - probably from the Roast Barley in there... but who knows? It could be from the shit brewer who made it. It's not really to style... regardless. The guidelines say specifically: "A very dark, roasty, bitter, creamy ale."
Well... 2 out of 4 aint bad! I have bitter and dark sorted out.
Now to figure out this "Creamy" character - and this "Roasty" one they speak of.
Dont get muddled!! Creamy is about the texture in your mouth, how does the mouthfeel compare to tui? both the same alc.
In my one I brewed it to style guidlines so to speak, but mine is far to bitter for me to like!! I like my darkies around 50% SG/IBU this is around 70 and to me it seems out of whack!!
Creamy as far as dry stouts go is hard to get without nitro I reckon.
What was the recipe? The standard 70-20-10 grist?
I used that and it came out pretty well, was also lacking the 'creaminess' but I reckon you'd have to up residuals and loose dry-ness to gain creaminess. That's where the nitro comes in I reckon.
I've got one warm conditioning now that is 88% pale malt and has no oats of any kind... definitely no nitro... US05 yeast... you've just to drink 'em warm and flat. Preferably through a handpump but straight from a keg is ok as long as you give it some liberal use with the kiwi-handpump.
I came up with a little theory yesterday... could be completely wrong but I'll put it out there anyway... I reckon the high percentage of flaked barley and the nitro is actually to compensate for the crappy cheap pale malt that the big G use.
In saying all this... my "Dry Stout" doesn't have a single grain roast barley in it so who am I to talk!!! I have brewed one in the past though that was 90% pale malt, 10% roast barley and it was delicous (can't believe it was 3.5 years ago!). I distinctly remember thinking that it tasted like Guiness should.